After the Great Welfare Reform bill was passed, Bill Clinton's signature success, some of us were constrained by reality to point out that when the Good Times Turned Bad, as they inevitably would, people's need for help was going to explode and the whole system would be aimed at making sure they didn't get it. Well, as predicted the economy has imploded due to the scams and illegal maneuverings of our financial institutions and here they come. Only it ain't the poor what's filling out the forms. It's the middle class.
For the first time since welfare was redefined a dozen years ago, weaning millions of poor Americans from monthly government checks, the deteriorating economy is causing a surge in welfare rolls in a growing number of states.
The swelling caseloads pose the first hard test of the premise behind transforming the old system of welfare, once considered an open-ended right, into a finite program built to provide short-term cash assistance and steer people quickly into jobs.
Though still a fraction of the size they were at their height in the mid-1990s, welfare rolls recently have begun to climb again in at least a dozen states, according to interviews with state officials. In other states, applications are rising, foreshadowing more people on welfare soon. The trend has spread across the District, Maryland and Virginia.
More striking is who is coming onto welfare and why. Here in Florida, as elsewhere, the new face of welfare includes people who have tumbled from the middle class -- and higher -- after losing jobs, savings and self-reliance. And some are returning to welfare years after they thought they had found permanent work and independence. In the county that includes Fort Myers, nearly 40 percent of the 812 people who applied for welfare in October had never before asked for help.
Amy Goldstein, the WaPo reporter, seems surprised. The tone of the article is one of "Look at this! Who could have predicted it?" which marks a conservative these days. Confirming that diagnosis is the absurd assumption that welfare was at any time anywhere "considered an open-ended right". Welfare rolls have been down not because more people found jobs - they didn't - but because they were thrown off whether they had or not - the old conservative trick of denying eligibility and then claiming no one was eligible so there was therefore no need for the program. No one ever considered welfare a "right". They considered not going hungry or frozen in the richest nation in the world a "right", perhaps, but that's hardly the same thing.
Recent Comments