« NYT Eds: Why Haven't the Dems Passed Holt's Bill? & Can We Save Our Oceans? | Main | Healthy Americans Against Reforming Medicine »


There are leaps of logic in that lambert post that fall short but this is the most jarring: "$350 billion a year is a lot of money to leave on the table, especially to prop up the business model of denying health care for profit."

I don't understand a line of reasoning that includes the idea that the insurance industry needs to be "propped up." "Propped up" isn't the same thing as being left in place with strong regulations to deal with and a competitor that will be cheaper, more efficient and available to everyone. If the PHIP option further entrenched the insurance industry, I'd see their point. In fact, I'm afraid that without enough support from the ground, we will end up with reform that looks like Medicare Advantage and Part D. But to suggest that a strong PHIP option (still in reach, by the way) would do that is unfathomable to me.

"propped up" - Polls and studies have shown quite clearly that, given a reasonable option, especially universal single payer, almost everyone would opt out of the system of private insurance altogether. lambert did jump over it but that's the fear, that's what the numbers show, and that's why NOT doing single-payer is in essence propping up an industry that would fall of its own weight if it wasn't a de facto monopoly.

The other problem is the effect of leaving the for-profits in place to game the system and make sure they rip off the lion's share. That's what happened in Mass and that oh-so-promising alternative is in dire trouble as a result.

Mass doesn't have a public health insurance plan option.

Polls and studies have shown quite clearly that, given a reasonable option, especially universal single payer, almost everyone would opt out of the system of private insurance altogether.

The polls I've seen and my personal experience tell me the opposite. Most people don't want to lose what they have - of course, most people are healthy and don't know that they don't have much.

Mass doesn't have a public health insurance plan option.

Um, yes it does. Or did. I was enrolled in it for a year. Low-income were eligible; you could go with a public plan they'd pay all of or keep your private plan (assuming you had one) and be slightly subsidized. There was also a plan for subsidizing (essentially) corporate health plans by filling in holes (which all the employer plans had - big ones) and/or by having the state pay part of an employer's contribution.

But not everyone could opt out of their private plan. Income levels above a certain point weren't eligible for a public option, I believe. It was intended less as competition than a healthcare safety net for those who were uninsured or way underinsured.

The intent of Obama's plan is different but its structure - or what we can guess about its structure by reading between the lines - seems eerily familiar to me and I see the same holes in the fabric that I saw in Mass: the insurance companies managed to get themselves a set-up that allowed them to cherrypick the best customers, let the expensive ones go on the state, and then game the system by continuing to refuse payment of claims for suspiciously dingy and technical reasons.

The best reason in the world to kill any sort of public-private plan is the way the insurance companies continue to lie, cheat, steal, crib, and deny legitimate treatments & claims. They have no sense of proportion any more and no sense of when they've gone too far. As long as they're involved, they will be focused on destroying any system they can't dominate, period. We need them OUT.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Bang for the Buck: Boosting the American Economy

Compassionate Conservatism in Action


  • "We are the deciders. And every single day, every single one of us needs to step outside and take some action to help stop this war."

  • Photobucket


  • "[O]ur time, our energy, should be spent in educating, agitating, organizing our fellow citizens in the workplace, in the neighborhood, in the schools. Our objective should be to build, painstakingly, patiently but energetically, a movement that, when it reaches a certain critical mass, would shake whoever is in the White House, in Congress, into changing national policy on matters of war and social justice."


  • "True religion will not let us fall asleep in the comfort of our freedom. Love thy neighbor is not a piece of advice, it's a command. ...

    God, my friends, is with the poor and God is with us, if we are with them. This is not a burden, this is an adventure."

The Reverend Al Sharpton

  • Ray wasn't singing about what he knew, 'cause Ray had been blind since he was a child. He hadn't seen many purple mountains. He hadn't seen many fruited plains. He was singing about what he believed to be.

    Mr. President, we love America, not because of all of us have seen the beauty all the time.

    But we believed if we kept on working, if we kept on marching, if we kept on voting, if we kept on believing, we would make America beautiful for everybody.


  • ''With adequate profit, capital is very bold. A certain 10 percent will ensure its employment anywhere; 20 percent will produce eagerness, 50 percent positive audacity; 100 percent will make it ready to trample on all human laws; 300 percent, and there is not a crime which it will not scruple, nor a risk it will not run, even to the chance of its owner being hanged.''

Join Us!

  • Member, Project Hamad

Happy 71st Anniversary Social Security!

  • Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting


Become a Proud Member of the Guppy Army



Count Me, Damnit!

Blog powered by Typepad
Member since 01/2004

Oh, I've Won Awards

alternative hippopotamus

Paperwight's Fair Shot

Your Liberal Media